Take Your Lumps
Can (or should) anything be done about lipomas (also known as fatty tumors)?
This 10-year-old dog had several lipomas surgically removed a few years ago, but most of them grew back, including a large one on his right shoulder/neck, one behind his left elbow, and the prominent one on his left side.
Gus was adopted after being diagnosed with an infiltrative lipoma in his shoulder that could not be removed. Fortunately, it does not bother him at all.
The usual recommendation for fatty tumors is to wait and watch. Sometimes lipomas develop rapidly but in most cases their growth is slow. They rarely cause problems unless they become exceptionally large or their location creates mechanical problems. For example, a lipoma in the armpit can affect a dogs gait, while one in the sternum (chest area) can cause discomfort whenever the dog lies down, and a lipoma in the neck area, if it grows large enough, can interfere with breathing and proper collar fit.
"I never do surgery on benign lipomas unless they are physically impeding ambulation or other function," says Stacey Hershman, DVM, of Hastings-on-Hudson, New York. "I never remove a lipoma for cosmetic reasons since I have seen dogs get ill or go into liver failure after lipoma surgery even though their pre-op bloods were normal. Therefore I recommend to my clients that we leave them alone unless there is a medical reason to remove them. A few years ago a dog came in with such a huge lipoma under his armpit that he could not walk, and I removed it for functional reasons."
Some lipomas grow so rapidly that they might be something else, such as a liposarcoma. This rare, malignant fatty tumor usually does not metastasize (spread to other parts of the body) although it can be aggressive and fast-growing. Other tumors that occur on or under the skin that could be mistaken for lipomas include sebaceous adenomas, mast cell tumors, hemangiosarcomas, and hemangiopericytomas. If there is any question about diagnosis, removal may be the safest option.
Occasionally lipomas invade connective tissue between muscles, tendons, bones, nerves, or joint capsules. Called infiltrative lipomas, these usually occur in the legs but can affect the chest, head, abdominal body wall, or perianal region. Infiltrative lipomas can cause pain, muscle atrophy, and lameness by interfering with movement. Unlike normal lipomas, infiltrative lipomas can be difficult to remove completely and often regrow. Infiltrative lipomas are most common in Labrador Retrievers and Doberman Pinschers.
Not all infiltrative lipomas cause problems. Suzi Faulkner is president of the Atlantic Rottweiler Rescue Foundation (ARRF), which rescued Gus, a 3-year-old Rottweiler, in January 2011. "Gus was pulled from a shelter in Tennessee " she says. "When our volunteers picked him up, they discovered a cluster of lumps around his shoulder blade. A veterinarian removed the small lumps, but the large lump had infiltrated Gus's shoulder and removing it would mean removing part of the shoulder. It tested benign, so it was left alone."
Faulkner feared that his lipoma would prevent Gus from finding a home, but Scott Adelman of Owings Mills, Maryland, fell in love with Gus and adopted him as soon as he recovered from surgery. A year and a half later, Adelman reports that Gus is able to run and play normally, and he is not in pain. "Gus is the best dog in the world," he says.
Some lipomas can be removed with just a sedative and local anesthetic. Surgery for large, inconveniently placed, or multiple lipomas requires general anesthesia. Ordinary lipomas rarely grow back after removal, but others may occur. Surgery for infiltrative lipomas is more complicated and these growths often recur within 3 to 16 months. Radiation therapy may prevent or delay their recurrence, while chemotherapy provides no benefit.
Small lipomas used to be injected with a 10-percent solution of calcium chloride, which caused the tumors to become smaller, but this treatment is no longer recommended because of the irritation and severe skin damage it causes.
Liposuction, the same procedure that vacuums fat out of humans in cosmetic surgery, is in many cases less invasive, less painful, and faster healing than surgical removal.
In 2006, a 12-year-old Kelpie-cross named Patch made headlines in Sydney, Australia, for being the first Australian dog to undergo liposuction. Patch had several lipomas, one of which, on his hind leg, threatened to cripple him within months. Remembering a European veterinarian who performed liposuction on a dog using the suction tool normally used to clean up fluids during surgery, an Australian vet suggested trying this approach on Patch. The hour-long procedure removed six fatty tumors weighing two kilograms (4.4 pounds, or 10 percent of Patch's body weight). He was soon happy and playful again.
In January 2007, the Journal of Small Animal Practice reported the liposuction removal of three giant lipomas from a dog in Leipzig, Germany. The extremely obese patient suffered from arthritis and hind-leg lameness plus irritation caused by an armpit lipoma. Previous treatment involving dietary weight loss and nonsteroidal anti-inflammatory drugs had failed. Liposuction of the three lipomas resulted in a three-kilogram weight loss (6.6 pounds, or 10 percent of the dog's body weight).
In a retrospective study published in July 2011, the Journal of Small Animal Practice reviewed the use of liposection on multiple lipomas from 20 dogs. The treatment successfully removed 73 of 76 lipomas (96 percent). Simple, encapsulated lipomas measuring less than 6 inches in diameter were the easiest to remove and resulted in minimal risk of complication. Giant lipomas contained fibrous material that interfered with the removal of fat and had a high risk of bruising, hematoma, and seroma (fluid-filled swelling), especially in the groin area. Regrowth occurred nine months to three years later in 28 percent of the lipomas. Liposuction is not recommended for infiltrative lipomas.
The newest lipoma treatment for dogs and humans is the injection of collagenase, an enzyme that breaks the peptide bonds in collagen, the fibrous protein that connects body tissues. Developed by BioSpecifics Technologies Corporation and marketed as XIAFLEX® in the U.S. and XI APEX" in Europe and Eurasia, col-lagena se is being tested in clinical trials.
One preliminary trial tested three healthy dogs with multiple subcutaneous lipomas that were benign, superficial, and easily measurable. One lipoma on each dog was injected with collagenase and another was left untreated for use as a control. Ninety days after injection, a CT scan showed that the treated lipomas on two of the dogs had disappeared completely and the third dog's treated lipoma was only 7 percent of its original size. By contrast, the control lipomas had grown. Altogether, the treated lipomas showed a 97-percent reduction in size while the untreated controls increased by 23 percent.
BioSpecifics has initiated a placebo-controlled, single-injection randomized Phase II clinical trial to evaluate the efficacy of XIAFLEX for treatment of benign subcutaneous lipomas in 32 canines in a study to be completed in 2013. This will be followed by a Phase III clinical trial before the product becomes commercially available. (See "Resources," in right sidebar, for details.)
Because lipomas are so common in overweight dogs, one obvious treatment is weight loss. In some cases, diet and exercise have reduced the size of existing lipomas and may have helped prevent new ones from developing. Even if your dog's lipomas don't shrink as a result, helping an overweight dog trim down should help her feel better and be more active.
Switching to a raw, grain-free diet has been said to help some dogs, although most raw diets are high in fat, which may be counterproductive.
Limiting vaccinations may help some dogs, especially if lipomas tend to occur after vaccination.
"In my practice I have been following numerous dogs who are now 6 to 14 years old," says Judith K. Herman, DVM, of Augusta, Maine. "So far these dogs, all of whom received minimal vaccinations and are fed raw, have not developed any lipomas. Most are Jack Russell Terriers, Belgian Tervurens, Labrador Retrievers, and Golden Retrievers."
While acupuncture involves the insertion of needles along the body's meridians, acupressure applies finger touch or massage to the same points. As Amy Snow and Nancy Zidonis explained in "Truly Healing Touch," (WDJ, March 2009) and other WDJ articles, the basic principle underlying the healing process is that vital substances nourish the body while moving harmoniously through it. Two of these vital substances are chi (or qi), which is life-promoting energy, and blood, a nutrient-rich body fluid. In Traditional Chinese Medicine, "blood" includes other body fluids, such as synovial fluid in the joints or the nutrient-rich fluid within the spinal column.
"My dog Oak was a lipoma creator of great dimension," says Snow, "and acupressure worked to resolve them for most of his life. In Traditional Chinese Medicine, a lipoma is a stagnation of body fluids. The challenge is to bring chi through the area to move or disperse the fluids. The longer they stay, the more difficult it is to resolve them because they become cold.' Additionally, the younger the dog, the more quickly lipomas can be resolved. As the dog ages, his system naturally slows down and this slowing leads to an increase in developing lipomas."
Even as a 2-year-old, Oak, who was an affectionate, easy-going Golden Retriever, created lipomas. "I'd run my hands over him almost every day to see if there were any new ones," she says. "I had him checked for hypothyroidism to see if his metabolism was normal, and it was. Oak's lustrous coat often hid the lipomas until they were obvious. But I did my best to locate them and get to work with acupressure massage, also called Tui Na in Chinese, as a way to increase the movement of chi and body fluids through each lipoma."
Oak started forming lipomas when he was just two years old. They continued to develop throughout his life, though his owner was able to resolve most of them with acupressure.
For six years, Snow resolved Oak's lipomas with these techniques. After age eight, although they remained small, his lipomas became a management issue and were not completely resolved. At age 11, one had to be removed because it hindered walking. The following year, Oak passed away with only a few minor lipomas.
"Lipomas are relatively superficial, just beneath the skin, and so are the meridians," says Snow. "That's why working along the meridians that pass through a lipoma works. If people use acupressure around a lipoma but not on meridian points, it will not be as effective and in fact may not be effective at all. Graduates of the Tallgrass Animal Acupressure Institute training program have shown the guardians/owners of dogs with lipomas how to perform some of these procedures on a consistent basis. Applying acupressure massage every day for six days, then taking a one-daybreak, then continuing for another five or six days and repeating the pattern until the lipoma is resolved seems to be an important element in ridding dogs of lipomas."
For best results, consult a canine acupressure practitioner who can show you exactly which acupoints affect energy flowing through a specific lipoma, or practice on your own with the help of Acu-Dog: A Guide to Canine Acupressure (see "Resources,"on right).
To treat Cayman's arthritis, his owner fed him curcumin - and found that it also helped reduce Cayman's lipomas. When the curcumin was stopped, the lipomas returned.
Herbs have been used for millennia to treat every type of condition, and today's science confirms the effectiveness of many ancient remedies. Turmeric (Curcuma longa), the root that gives Indian curries their distinctive color and flavor, has a long history of use in Ayurveda, the traditional medicine of East India, especially for digestive disorders and arthritis. Curcumin is the active ingredient responsible for turmeric's anti-inflammatory and antioxidant properties.
Andrew Stowe of Fairfax, Virginia, gave turmeric root powder to Cayman, his 13-year-old yellow Lab/hound-mix, as part of a treatment for arthritis. Cayman had developed six large and medium-sized lipomas, and while he was taking turmeric, three of them disappeared and the others shrank. After six months the arthritis treatment stopped working (Cayman began limping again), so Stowe discontinued the treatment. The dog's lipomas returned and he developed even more. Stowe thinks the turmeric may have suppressed their growth.
The protocol Stowe followed for 80-pound Cayman combined turmeric powder with other supplements, beginning with a four-week dose of la teaspoon turmeric powder morning and evening; then two weeks at 1/4 teaspoon twice per day; then 1/2 teaspoon twice per day.
It's a good idea to begin any herbal treatment with small doses and increase gradually to the recommended amount, which in the case of turmeric is often 1/2 teaspoon for small dogs, 1/4 teaspoon for medium-sized dogs and 1 teaspoon for large dogs daily. Give with food to prevent stomach upsets. Be sure your turmeric is Curcuma longa (verify the herb's Latin name) and not an inexpensive substitute, and, because turmeric dyes everything yellow, wash your hands after handling.
Curcumin extract is much more concentrated than the powdered root. Recommended dosage varies, but one product made for dogs suggests giving 20 to 60 mg per 10 pounds of body weight daily. Higher doses, up to 2,000 mg twice a day for a large dog, are used to treat dogs with cancer. Combining curcumin with bromelain may increase absorption.
Herbalist Ingrid Naiman developed "Stone Free" Herbal Support for Kidney and Gallbladder using turmeric and other herbs. "It emulsifies fat," she says. "We have seen it completely remove fatty deposits under the skin."
Alyssia Greiner of Manassas, Virginia, tried a Chinese herbal treatment for her 9-year-old Border Collie, Zippity, when she developed a large lipoma on her right shoulder, another on her right ribcage, and a small one inside her left leg. Her vet prescribed "Cluster Dissolving," a traditional blend of 11 Chinese herbs.
"Zip has been on it for about six months," says Greiner, "and there is a definite difference in size and softness. The one on her shoulder used to feel like a softball and people would freak out when they felt it, but several people familiar with her think it feels smaller, softer, and more pliable. The one on her leg felt like a large marble but is now softer and smaller. The rib cage lipoma feels very loose and fluid now. I don't think they will dissolve completely, but as long as they are not getting bigger, I'm happy."
Although homeopathy is often recommended as a support therapy for lipomas, many veterinary homeopaths report little or no success with homeopathy as a standalone treatment for fatty tumors.
Dr. Judith Herman in Augusta, Maine, is a veterinary homeopath, former president of the Academy of Veterinary Homeopathy, and chair of its certification committee. Classically trained homeopaths such as Dr. Herman use single remedies (not combinations) in response to their patients' specific symptoms. "The correct remedy is the one that matches the patient's whole picture," says Dr. Herman. "Lipomas are part of the chronic disease picture, not single entities."
Zippity has three lipomas. Her owner believes that a Traditional Chinese herbal remedy is helping to limit the growth of the lipomas.
In 2004, Dr. Herman treated Anna, a 1-year-old Golden Retriever, for masticatory muscle myositis, an inflammatory muscle disease that produces jaw pain or an inability to open the jaw. At the time, Anna was eating grocery store kibble and taking prednisone. "Because she had diarrhea and her owners weren't ready to forego allopathic treatment," she says, "I suggested changing her food to a raw, home-prepared diet."
Prednisone was discontinued After symptoms resolved, but when they returned, Dr. Herman treated Anna homeopathically. Within two months, her mouth functioned normally, but Anna later returned with a soft lump on her chest, which was diagnosed as a lipoma, and she again showed mild signs of myositis. She received the same homeopathic remedy as before but at a higher potency. One month later her mouth was back to normal and the lipoma had disappeared. "Anna has had normal yearly visits since then without any sign of illness," says Dr. Herman. "In 2010 she developed a yeast infection in her ears and I treated her with the same remedy as in 2004 because her symptom picture still matched the remedy. Her ears were fine within a month, and she is still doing well."
Stephen Blake, DVM, of San Diego, California, reports, "I had a case at a no-kill shelter where an 8-year-old Shepherd-mix had a lipoma almost the size of a basketball on his back, hanging over his side. It was so big that the dog had problems running. I treated him once with homeopathic Thuja 10M and within a month it dissolved. After two months all that was left was a large sack of skin hanging on the dog's back.
The same homeopathic remedy was used to successfully treat Anna's lipomas, masticatory muscle myositis, and a yeast infection in her ears.
"My reasoning for prescribing the Thuja was the fact that he had been vaccinated prior to the appearance of the lipoma. Homeopathic Thuja is a good choice in cases like this, where a lipoma appears after a vaccination."
Aromatherapy's essential oils (see "Essential Information," WDJ January 2005) may help lipomas in some cases. Dr. Blake says, "As part of the healing protocol for all tumors, I use a combination of frankincense (Boswellia spp.), sandalwood (Santalum album), and Douglas fir (Pseudotsuga menziesii) to aid the body in its detoxification and healing process. I have the owner massage a small amount of these oils into the tumor daily until the body has no need for it."
Canine aroma therapist Frances Fitzgerald Cleveland of Littleton, Colorado, uses full-strength grapefruit essential oil (Citrus x paradise), which is not a distilled essential oil but rather cold-pressed from the peel of fresh fruit. "This is a very cooling, cleansing, and decongesting oil, like lemon," she says. "Grapefruit oil helps the body eliminate excess fluids and break down fats, plus it promotes a lightness of spirit. It is my first choice when working with lipomas. I find it aids in clearing the lymphatic system, helps with congestion of the skin, and is a tonic to the system. I have used it on two of my dogs with great success in keeping their existing lipomas from getting any larger and shrinking some to a smaller size.
Essential oils are usually diluted before being applied to dogs, but one or two drops of therapeutic-quality frankincense or grapefruit essential oil can safely be applied to an adult dog's lipoma once or twice per day.
While lipomas can be unsightly, they are generally harmless and rarely cause problems. This is one situation where doing nothing is a completely acceptable option, once the diagnosis has been verified. Be thankful knowing that your dog has nothing worse than a lump of fat and not a cancerous tumor.
CJ Puotinen lives in Montana. She is the author of The Encyclopedia of Natural Pet Care and other books and a frequent contributor to WDJ. See page 24 for book purchasing information.
Mary Straus is the owner of DogAware.com. She lives with her Norwich Terrier, Ella, in the San Francisco Bay Area.
Some are reluctant to perform surgery on old dogs because of anesthesia risks or complications, but these risks are minimal in the case of most lipomas. Modern anesthesia protocols are far safer than they used to be, and complications are generally minor, usually limited to superficial infection or delayed healing. There is no reason not to remove lipomas from older dogs when they interfere with their quality of life.
Tia Nelson examined a 12-year-old Lab whose owners had made the painful decision to put her down because she just couldn't get around any more. But her problem wasn't old age, it was a five-pound lipoma on her side just behind and partly under her shoulder blade. "I removed it," says Dr. Nelson, "and the dog enjoyed another two years."
In a report published on his blog "Your Pet's Best Friend," Everett Mobley, DVM, of Kennett, Missouri, describes the case of Ling Ling, a 15-year-old Collie-mix who developed a large tumor in front of her left shoulder. "It was about 6 inches long, 3 inches wide and 1.5 inches thick, which is pretty big, even for a 57-pound dog," he says. "We did a fine-needle aspiration and it turned out to be a lipoma. Because Ling Ling was so elderly and the tumor was large enough to require lengthy surgery, plus it didn't seem to bother her, we decided it was something she would probably die with, instead of something she would die from."
|The mass on Ling Ling's shoulder before surgery.||Two months after surgery, Ling Ling is far more comfortable|
But in May 2012, Ling Ling lost weight while her tumor grew. "It grew so much," says Dr. Mobley, "that it appeared to have disrupted its own blood supply. There was a nasty-looking bulge that looked like it would soon die and rot and burst open. Not so good. She made it through 90 minutes of surgery like a champ. The tumor was so big it was like delivering a baby. It weighed three pounds and was as big as her head."
Because the mass had disrupted the attachment of Ling Ling's shoulder muscles, Dr. Mobley re-attached them. She made a full recovery.
"LIPOSUCTION FOR REMOVAL OF LIPOMAS IN 20 DOGS"
by GB Hunt, et al. Journal of Small Animal Practice, 2011 Aug; 52(8):419-25.
"LIPOSUCTION: REMOVAL OF GIANT LIPOMAS FOR WEIGHT LOSS IN A
DOG WITH SEVERE HIP OSTEOARTHRITIS"
by P. Bottcher, et al. Journal of Small Animal Practice, 2007 Jan;48(1):46-8.
"TOO OLD FOR TUMOR SURGERY?"
by Everett Mobley, DVM.
ACU-DOG: A GUIDE TO CANINE ACUPRESSURE
by Amy Snow and Nancy Zidonis. Tallgrass Publishers, 2011, paperback, 188 pages, $33
STONE FREE, BY PLANETARY HERBALS
Ingrid Naiman, (800) 606-6226; planetaryherbals.com
CLUSTER DISSOLVING, BY KAN HERB COMPANY
(800) 543-5233; kanherb.com
CURCUVET, BY THORNE RESEARCH
(800) 228-1966, veterinary.thorne.com
XIAFLEX (INJECTABLE COLLAGENASE), BIOSPECIFICS TECHNOLOGY
(516) 593-7000, biospecifics.com. Dogs with benign subcutaneous lipomas may be eligible to participate in a clinical trial conducted in Carlsbad, CA, by California Veterinary Specialists. For info, contact Dr Sarit Dhupa, sarit.dhupa@
gmail.com, or Janette Velez, jvelez@
calvetspec.com; (760) 431-2273
CANINE AROMATHERAPY PRODUCTS, BY FROGWORKS
Frances Fitzgerald Cleveland, Littleton, CO. (877) 973-8848; ffrogworks.com
TALLGRASS ANIMAL ACUPRESSURE INSTITUTE, LARKSPUR, CO
Amy Snow, Nancy Zidonis, and practitioner referrals. (303) 681-3033; animalacupressure
ATLANTIC ROTTWEILER RESCUE FOUNDATION (ARRF)
Mooresville, NC. (704) 929-2304; arrfnc.com
STEPHEN BLAKE, DVM. San Diego, CA. (858) 566-3588; thepetwhisperer
JUDITH K. HERMAN, DVM Augusta, ME. (207) 623-1177; mainehomeopathic
STACEY HERSHMAN, DVM
Hastings-on-Hudson, NY. (914) 478-4100; www.natural
EVERETT MOBLEY, DVM
Kennett, MO. (573) 888-2255; www.yourpets
TIA NELSON, DVM. Helena, Ml (406) 442-0188; tdbhelena.com